Two private varsities watched for producing poor quality docs
PUTRAJAYA (Jan 18, 2007): Two private universities are being watched by the Health Ministry over complaints that they produced poor quality doctors.
Health Minister Datuk Seri Dr Chua Soi Lek said the complaints were not only on this aspect but also on the fact that they were training too many medical students and not sticking to the fixed teacher-to-student ratio.
He said the fixed ratio is 1:6 or 1:8 but the universities concerned used a 1:20 ratio.
“There are complaints of doctors produced by these universities were not as good as they should be.
“Universiti Malaya (UM) which set up its medical faculty a long time ago, only produces 200 medical officers a year but these two universities produce 300 although they were set up about 10 years ago,” he told reporters after attending a dialogue with students from UM, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia (UKM) and Universiti Putra Malaysia (UPM) here today.
Bernama quoated Chua as saying that seven private universities were offering medical courses and the government was collecting particulars on them.
If the universities were found to have contravened regulations, action could be taken against them, including warning them or their duration of courses would not be extended, he said.
First we had only 3 universities that offered medical education. At that time, the quality of medical education was excellent and impressive. This was going on for years. Then over the last decade, we saw many medical universities coming up. They grew so rapidly and blatantly, that medical education in the 3 main universities were affected. Senior clinicians left to the new institutions in view of promotion. So rampant it was, that professors and associate professors were given to those without caliber. There was no control as many reaped profits from medical education. Everything became worse when political parties decided to have one each by their own — just to widen racial differances. As more medical universities sprout, the countries leading university were going through brain drain so severe that some department that were once a pride of the nation were now a laughing stock. As medical universities sprout, more and more younger fresh graduates became lectures without the much needed experience. Medical students have now lost great teachers thus losing idols that moulded many older doctors to achieve what is expectedly excellent quality. With the loss of idols or role models, the quest for quality dropped as now their role models were fresh graduates from masters or membership examinations joining these institution to attain a better pay, name and better future prospect in private. Nobody cared for the developement of quality medical students - very few did! Many realised the importance of this institutions as a stepping stone to the private sector.
So is this all a surprise? Well I am surprised that it took them this long to realise that there is no quality control in Malaysia in anything. Everything is set for auto-run mode. For such a small country like Malaysia, we have too many medical universities. Quantity is of importance for the government because quantity is money not quality! Why? Because the public is such a tolerant one that we Malaysians will accept anything thrown to us whether it is of quality or otherwise! The general public is happy that many are passing exams and many get the chance to go to university especially many are able to do medicine. Well the truth is, the passing mark and standards have been brought so low that one will still pass his physics or biology by getting 20/100. The general student now who enters university are becoming ill-prepared for university-like structure and are far below par. Many senior lecturers in these universiy will agree with this. To make things worse the education ministry and universities then revise their syllabus to make it easier and lighter to allow many more to pass. Noticed the use of many rather than better.
The government has plenty to do. As many of my previous post, the public must start to rise and work together to voice their need for not just mediocre service but excellent service and the government must better up with a fairer system then the present nonsense system (SSM).